What Do You Know About Learning?
Comedy, Transgression, and Cosmopolitanism


XIDS 2002-01

 
Spring 2010  

Tu, Th 12:30-1:20 p.m.  Pafford 209



Dr. Lori Lipoma


Pafford 323 
llipoma@westga.edu
 (678) 839-4873

Office Hours:
Mon, Tu, Th 10:00 to noon

and by appointment



Required Texts 

Syllabus
 
 
 Learning Objectives
Course
 Requirements

Attendance

 
Grading and
"Five Habits of Mind"

Links to visuals
we'll be discussing class 

 

Comedy holds the key to peaceful co-existence in our turbulent, mind-boggling, ever-encroaching global society?

Who knew??!?!

Kwame Anthony Appiah argues that as we discover new areas of global interconnectedness and diversity, we are simultaneously having to confront and navigate the deep cultural and ideological differences that divide us. Appiah provides a model for how we can learn to balance the demands of society and the needs of the individual. Through our own “imaginative engagement,” Appiah argues that cosmopolitanism balances our "obligations to others" with the "value not just of human life, but of particular human lives."

In this course, we will discover that one way we can learn to live in this difficult practice of imaginative engagement is through laughter. Comedy helps us to cope with fear and stress, think critically about our lives and our world, and lead individual lives, retaining our own distinctiveness, while still functioning amid the conflicts of global citizenship.

In “Comedy, Transgression, and Cosmopolitanism,” we will first study Appiah’s theories about living , then humor theory, and finally, we’ll examine the intersection of both within some of the funniest writing, stand-up, TV, and movies we’ve ever seen.




 

L EARNING OBJECTIVES 

Students will:
•   read theoretical works on comedy, transgression, and cosmopolitanism; in addition, they will read humorous essays and novels, and watch stand-up
     comedians, mockumentaries, and comedy films.  

•   demonstrate the ability to approach these primary and secondary texts critically, and to develop and express an interpretation of them as they relate to      global citizenship.
•  write bi-weekly response papers that examine primary texts with respect to theoretical concepts, deliver ten-minute presentations analyzing and  
    evaluating a comedic text of their own choosing, and participate in active, engaged class discussions.
•  demonstrate through class discussion and writing assignments an understanding of the  intersection between comedy, transgression, and global
    citizenship.  
• demonstrate a command of academic English and of the tenets of sound composition by writing thesis-driven analytical prose.
  

 
We're going to read a lot, talk a lot, and move quickly...but we'll also have a whole lot of fun--
all your efforts will very rewarding if you hold up your end of the bargain as an engaged,
 committed student who meets deadlines and thinks deeply about course material.

 
   

REQUIRED TEXTS --All these titles are available at the University Bookstore.  

•  Appiah, Kwame Anthony.  Cosmopolitanism:  Ethics in a World of Strangers. NY:  W. W. Norton, 2007.
•  Limon, John.  Stand-up Comedy in Theory, or, Abjection in America.  Duke UP:  2000.
•  Course Pack:  What Do You Know About Comedy?  Comedy, Transgression, and Cosmopolitanism.
•  Maimon, Elaine P. A Writer's Resource: A Handbook for Writing and Research (Second Edition)   NY: McGraw-Hill Higher Education.



NOTE:  I expect that students will bring each text to class on the day we're scheduled to discuss it.

Films--available on Netflix or Blockbuster.com--you must watch this movie in time for class assignment and discussion:        
•  Deconstructing Harry.   Woody Allen, dir.  Woody Allen, Bob Balaban, Billy Crystal, perf.  Sweetland Films, 1997.
•  Team America:  World Police.   Trey Parker dir.  Trey Parker and Matt Stone, perf.  Paramount Pictures, 2004.


COURSE REQUIREMENTS AND GRADING

  Five 1-1/2 to 2-page response papers:  10% each / 50% cumulative
        Midterm exam:  10%
    Participation:  10%
    Reading and viewing quizzes:  10%
Final paper:  20%

Students must have passed ENGL 1102 with a C or better in order to register for this class.


 
1. Reading Responses—50% cumulative; 5 total
These essays, which comprise the largest portion of your semester grade, will consist of brief (1-1/2 to 2 pages, typed, MLA formatting,  including a Works Cited page ) responses to our readings.  You must turn in FIVE of these during the semester between Week 2 and Week 15—I don’t accept multiple submissions, and I only accept one per class meeting.  In other words, you have thirteen weeks (twenty-six class periods, give or take) in which to complete five separate reading responses.  Refer to the syllabus for submission schedule/deadlines.

Please see my comments below regarding the quality I'm expecting in these important writing/learning assignments.

Interdisciplinary Aim:   We will accomplish four important learning outcomes with these responses: (1) to insure that students read consistently, carefully, and on time; (2) to help you prepare for in-class discussion of the readings; (3) to learn and apply college-level terminology that you will need to master in their upper division writing;  (4) to give you sustained practice in polished college-level critical writing. 

 
2. Final Paper—20%
A formal three- to four-page analysis of a comedic text of your own choosing with respect to course theory and discussion.  We'll talk in much more depth about this project as the semester progresses; you must meet several milestones leading up to this assignment, including submitting a formal proposal for your primary text, a provisional thesis/abstract for your paper, and at least one visit to the University Writing Center in the drafting process.

Interdisciplinary Aim:  (1) To apply course concepts in the analysis of a text relevant to this semester's study; (2) to hone skills of writing in college-level, standard English, and to articulate complex ideas in this mode of communication.  


SAMPLE  ESSAYS:  Here's an A-level analytical paper ;  here's a sample F-level essay .

 3. Class Participation (10%)
This will include preparedness with outside readings and informal written assignments, contributions to discussion, engagement in conversations with the professor and other students, and participation in various class activities (such as work in small groups, reflective writing, etc.).  

Interdisciplinary Aim:  Active class participation is vital to the success of the course, and will necessitate reflection and analysis in verbal, written, and graphic form.  



4.  Reading and Viewing Quizzes (10%)
I will occasionally give a brief quiz in order to assure that you're doing your reading and viewing for each class session so that we can have a truly collaborative discussion each and every meeting.

Interdisciplinary Aim:  Informed class participation is vital to the success of any course, and because students in an XIDS class come from varying disciplinary viewpoints, everyone's contribution is important.  I want you to be able to tell me what you think about a given concept or text, articulate your agreement or disagreement with it, back up your argument with thoughtful evidence, and listen and genuinely consider others' opinions as well.



REQUIREMENTS FOR ALL PAPERS
I consider your response papers and your research papers to be formal, college-level writing assignments, and I hope you will take them as seriously as I do.  They must meet or exceed the following standards in order to earn a passing grade (or higher):

• You must type and format all out-of-class papers in MLA style (see Writer's Resource Tab 6).  
• Papers must demonstrate that you care about their quality:  stretch your imagination in order to find complex and innovative topics upon which to
   write, spellcheck, proofread (read your paper aloud), integrate comments/corrections I've noted on previous papers in all your subsequent writing,
   cite your sources thoroughly, look up correct punctuation and grammar, etc.
• Essays must have adequate in-text citations and a Works Cited page.
• All your papers must be stapled in the top left corner.
• Successful college-level essays must demonstrate that you're synthesizing and analyzing class materials.  Response papers should focus on one
    or two elements of a text, and must go deeper than a simplistic "I liked this comic because..." type of reflective response.
 
• In assessing your writing assignments, I will apply the English Department grading rubric for First Year Writing students. 

In all your out-of-class assignments, I will expect you to refer to your Writer's Resource in order to write polished, grammatically-precise, MLA formatted, college-level essays.

Please note:  I do not accept electronic submissions of any out-of-class work.



Spring 2009--IMPORTANT DATES
**Last day to withdraw with a “W”:  March 2nd

University-wide classes cancelled on the following days:

January 19th:  MLK Day Observance   
March 16-20th: Spring Break
April 4:  Honors Convocation; classes cancelled 1:00-4:00 p.m.


 
A FINAL NOTE: 
We’re going to have fun this semester, but earning high grades in this class will require lots of effort and discipline on your part.  With this in mind, please

read the following excerpt, "Five Habits of Mind," from From Students to Citizens and Workers: An Interview with Deborah Meier   by Janice Molloy, which briefly outlines the intellectual skills you'll need to continue cultivating in order to succeed in this (and any other) college course:


1. Evidence : How do we know what's true and false?
What evidence counts? How sure can we be?
What makes it credible to us?

2. Viewpoint : How else might this look if we stepped into other shoes? If we were looking at it from a different direction?
If we had a different history or expectations?

3. Connections/Cause and Effect : Is there a pattern?
Have we seen something like this before?
What are the possible consequences?

4. Conjecture : Could it have been otherwise?
Supposing that? What if?

5. Relevance : Does it matter? Who cares?

The habits of mind are supplemented by habits of work: meeting deadlines, being on time, sticking to a task, not getting frustrated quickly, listening to what others say, and striving
to accomplish more than the bare minimum.


http://www.pegasuscom.com/levpoints/meierint.html

ATTENDANCE
The only way we can achieve our course objectives is through your consistent attendance and participation in class.  However, I know that occasional emergencies arise, so I allow FOUR no-questions-asked absences—please use them wisely, and keep me informed!   NOTE:  I count "lates" (i.e. arriving after class has begun) as 1/2 an absence...so please be on time!

I don't distinguish between "excused" and  "unexcused" absences; you owe me no explanations nor documentation for your absences; all I ask is that you use these absences wisely. 

If you must be absent, I expect you to keep up with the assignments; if you’re absent on the day an assignment is due, I will still expect you to make arrangements to get it to me on time. Students who are absent receive a zero for in-class work missed; more than four absences will result in a 5 point reduction of your final grade. Excessive absences (six or more) will result in administrative withdrawal from class.

I will ask any student who falls asleep during class to leave my classroom, and will count that student absent for the day.



LATE WORK
I will not accept late work (I know this policy is challenging—but I really do mean it, and I don't make exceptions).   Being late with assignments hinders your progress—and often, that of the entire class! Although it's far easier just to hand in your paper at the beginning of class on the due date, my definition of a late paper is one that  you haven't placed in my hands before I leave campus on the day the assignment's due.   

PLAGIARISM AND ACADEMIC HONESTY
The Department of English and Philosophy defines plagiarism as taking personal credit for the words and ideas of others as they are presented in electronic, print, and verbal sources; an equally dishonest practice is fabricating sources or facts, which is another form of misrepresenting the truth.  I expect, therefore, that students will accurately and thoroughly credit sources in all their assignments.   

I will give an automatic "F" in this course to any student who plagiarizes or excessively collaborates on any assignment (quizzes, out-of-class essays, and journals). . . no exceptions.  In order to be crystal clear on what I, the English Department, and the University expect of you in regard to academic honesty, please review all the links below--I hold each of my students responsible for having read and understood these policies:

Plagiarism--Definition and Prevention   
http://www.westga.edu/~engdept/Plagiarism/pladef.html

  The Faculty Handbook, sections 207 and 208.0401
  http://www.westga.edu/~vpaa/handrev/

  Student Uncatalogue: "Rights and Responsiblities"; Appendix J.
  http://www.westga.edu/handbook/


TENTATIVE COURSE SYLLABUS
Certain to change from time to time (in order to meet
our class's needs as they evolve thoughout the semester),
so check this schedule at least once per week!!!

Readings and assignments are due on the day they're noted.


Everybody's for diversity, social cohesion, inclusion...But what does any of it mean?...Most people intuitively sense that the vocabulary used by public figures consists of platitudes masquerading as meaningful political idioms... Take a key HURRAH WORD:  diversity.  Diversity has no intrinsic political or moral meaning...[it] merely provides a rhetorical strategy for avoiding the challenging task of outlining what society stands for by claiming that it stands for anything.-- Frank Furedi




UNIT I:  Picking up the threads of the conversation, identifying our sensibilities, and setting up frameworks for analysis.

WEEK 1
 01/07  Th:   Intro to XIDS 2002--Five Habits of Mind, Writer’s Resource, and other First Day of Class stuff.  Discussion:  values, truth, and learning cosmopolitanism.  Please print out this list of reading selections for inclusion in your Course Pack.



WEEK 2 First week for submitting response essays.
01/13  Tu:     Appiah, Introduction pp. xi-xxi and ch 1, pp.1-11.  Cross-cultural conversations--case study:   Obama inauguration and Rick Warren.
01/15  Th:     CP:   Zilvys, “Obscene Humor:  What the Hell?”  Discussion:  The comic perspective.


 
WEEK 3
01/20   Tu:      CP:  Morreall, “Humor in the Holocaust.”  Religion in humor:  Marcus Brigstocke:  “Can We Have Our Planet Back?” and excerpts from Monty Python, The Meaning of Life; South Park, Eddie Izzard, Penn and Teller, Bullshit .
01/22   Th:     CP:  Foucault, "Preface to '“Transgression'," pp. 57-63.  King, “Why We Crave Horror Movies.”  “Lenny Bruce—A Thinking Man’s Comedian” and Carlin, “Seven Words.”



WEEK 4
01/27   Tu:    Limon, Introduction—read pp. 1 through the break halfway down p. 8.  Also, print and read this brief definition of  "the abject."  
01/29   Th:    YouTube assignment:  watch this scene from Monty Python's The Meaning of Life, and take notes on the instances of abjection and
transgression you observe in the characters, the lyrics, and the scene itself.   What critical, cohesive, and superiority functions do you think the this scene might serve?  
Discussion:  Race and humor.  Race Matters:  excerpts from Tom Lehrer, “National Brotherhood Week,” Lenny Bruce, Richard Pryor/George Carlin,
Dave Chappelle, Margaret Cho.

Looking ahead:  1)  Your reading assignment for Thursday is lengthier than usual--please plan ahead and be ready to discuss the entire assignment on 2/05;  2) You must have watched (and taken notes on) Woody Allen’s Deconstructing Harry by Thursday, 2/12.
   


WEEK 5
02/03   Tu:     CP:  Koestler, The Act of Creation, Chapter II:  "Laughter and Emotion" pp. 51-63.  ALSO, watch this Margaret Cho clip. ALSO, selecting cultural texts for the balance of the semester; schedule sign-up.
02/05   Th:    Appiah, ch 2 and 3, pp. 13-44.  Excerpts from Da Ali G Show and Margaret Cho (watch this out of class:  see 2/03 for link).



WEEK 6
02/10  Tu:    Limon, ch. 5, pp. 83-103.   Student selection:  Chatty Katty (Roberts)
2/12  Th:     Woody Allen and the abject:  Deconstructing Harry Bring your viewing notes to class!

INTERESTING ARTICLE ON PSYCHOLOGY OF SCATOLOGY AND OTHER ABJECT TOPICS IN HISTORY


WEEK 7
02/17  Tu:      Appiah, ch 4, pp. 45-68.  Student selection:    Boondocks (Franklin).  Discussion:  Midterm exam (10% of your semester grade, 2/26/09)
02/19  Th:      Student selection: Proper English:  Ellen DeGeneres, "The Beginning 7" (Qualls).



UNIT II:     Examining and analyzing current conversations              


WEEK 8
02/24  Tu:     Limon, ch. 6, pp. 104-123.   Student selection:  Carol Burnett/Robin Williams
02/26  Th:    Midterm.  Do not be late for today's exam period!  PREPARE FOR YOUR TEST:   HERE IS THE EXAM!!

           You must bring:  1.  large (8-1/2 x 11) blank (blue cover) examination book (34 cents at the University Book Store)
                                       2.  your course pack, Limon's Stand-Up Comedy in Theory, and Appiah's Cosmopolitanism
                                       
3.  a well-prepared brain; remember--you must complete this test in 45 minutes
                                           (the clip is four minutes long), so STUDY by practicing with other comedy clips we've already studied.

PLEASE NOTE:  IF YOU COME TO CLASS ON THURSDAY UNPREPARED
(I.E. YOU DON'T HAVE ALL OF THE ABOVE MATERIALS WITH YOU, READY TO GO),
YOU'LL BE DISMISSED FROM THE CLASSROOM.  NO MAKE-UP EXAMS; NO EXCEPTIONS.  
(Harsh, yes, but I do mean it, so be prepared!)
 


 

Monday, March 2nd:  **Last Day to Withdraw with a W**
 


WEEK 9
03/03  Tu:     Appiah, ch 5, pp. 69-86.  (Discussion:  Final paper proposal.)
03/05  Th:     Student selection:  Blanchard:  excerpt from   Family Guy .


Looking ahead:  You must have watched (and taken notes on) Trey Parker and Matt Stone’s  Team America:  World Police by Tuesday, 3/24.
   
Be thinking about your final paper (proposal due 3/26); it must be three pages in length, and it must examine the way that TWO transgressively comedic texts contend with the same cross-cultural question/debate/problem.  In your proposal, (one or two paragraphs, typed, double-spaced, MLA format)  you must tell me:
-- the two texts you intend to analyze 
-- why you think they are significant with respect to our focus of study this semester, and
-- the three critical texts you will apply to these primaries in your analysis (one of these texts MUST BE Cosmopolitanism).  

Your final paper should arrive at a conclusion/interpretation about how the comedic treatments of a serious topic enable or advance the cross-cultural conversation.


WEEK 10   
03/10  Tu:    Student selections: Roach:  excerpt from Robin Williams Live on Broadway.
03/12  Th:    Response paper-writing:  remember--you must complete five this semester; see ESSAY GRADING RUBRIC, above.

 
WEEK 11--Spring Break!!  Woo Hoo!!


 
Unit III:  Joining cultural conversations

WEEK 12
03/24  Tu:   Appiah, ch 6, pp. 87-100. 
                    Student selection: Tidwell, "The Ten"; Goodroe, selection from Marvel/DC
03/26  Th:    Final paper proposal due.  Parker and Stone, Team America: World Police . Bring your viewing notes to class!



WEEK 13 
03/31  Tu:     Appiah, ch 7, pp. 101-114  Student selection: Stuckey, excerpt from Juno; Owensby, TBA.
04/02  Th:     Student selection:  Dolder, excerpt from Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back.
                 


WEEK 14
04/07  Tu:     Appiah, ch 8, pp. 115-136.Student selection: Chalkley, Ellen DeGeneres:  "We Are All Gay."
04/09  Th    No class today; I will be at a conference.



WEEK 15 Last week for submitting response essays.
04/14  Tu:    Appiah, ch 9, pp. 137-154.  Student selection:  Bennett, satire of Lord of the Rings.
04/16  Th:    Paper conferences/independent work:  no class meeting. Contact me for appointment if necessary.

 
WEEK 16
04/21   Tu:     Student selection: Hocutt, excerpt from Death to Smoochie, Skaggs:  "Clayton Biggsby" from The Chapelle Show; Pressley, TBA.
04/23   Th:      Paper conferences/independent work:  no class meeting.   Contact me for appointment if necessary.



WEEK 17
04/28  Tu       Last Day of Classes!  Final paper due.
 


 





 
 

Have a Happy Summer!!!